SEO vs. AEO: The New Rules for Winning on Google and AI Models

Key Takeaways
SEO traffic is broadly flat; AI search is growing alongside it: SEO traffic has not meaningfully declined, while LLM usage is growing around 100% year over year. The growth of AI search is additive rather than simply shifting traffic away from Google.
SEO and AEO should be one blended strategy: Most strategies that work for AEO overlap with SEO, with SEO work often benefiting AEO automatically. The biggest differences are the importance of specific off-site citations and the opportunity to target highly specific long-tail questions.
Company stage should determine how you invest in SEO and AEO: Seed-stage companies should spend little to no time on SEO, increasing investment at Series A and significantly investing in SEO and AEO at Series B. AEO can produce faster impact for newer companies by getting mentioned in third-party citations.
AEO off-site strategy starts with the prompts you want to win: Identify valuable prompts, track which URLs appear as citations for those prompts, and target those specific sources for mentions. Unlike SEO, where links from broadly authoritative sites can matter, AEO depends heavily on the specific URLs appearing in the citations for the prompts you care about.
AEO creates a major opportunity in the ultra-long tail: Highly specific prompts can combine features, use cases, integrations, languages, and other criteria. Reddit, sales calls, customer-support conversations, and other places where customers ask real questions can help uncover this long tail.
Summary
Traditional search remains a major channel as LLM-driven discovery grows alongside it, making AI search an expansion of the search landscape rather than a replacement for SEO. The conversation examines where SEO and AEO share the same underlying mechanics and where AI search introduces new opportunities.
A key focus is the much larger long tail created by highly specific prompts, where visibility can depend on having the right information available and appearing in the sources cited by AI answers. Company stage shapes when AEO investment makes sense, and Reddit, sales calls, and support conversations can reveal what people are really asking.
The conversation closes with Ethan’s predictions for autonomous agents, more personalized search experiences, and the growing importance of unique expert content and video as inputs for LLMs. He emphasizes that many AEO tactics remain unproven and encourages marketers to run reproducible experiments and share their findings.
It’s additive. It’s not taking from search and moving to LLMs. It’s adding on top of it.
Ethan Smith, CEO of Graphite


